Skip to toolbar

At Mt. Rushmore and the White House, Trump Updates ‘American Carnage’ Message for 2020

At Mt. Rushmore and the White House, Trump Updates ‘American Carnage’ Message for 2020

His ominous remarks were a concession to his political standing: trailing in the polls, lacking a booming economy or a positive message to campaign on, and leaning on culture wars to buoy his loyalists.

President Trump looked on during a military plane flyover at Mount Rushmore on Friday.
President Trump looked on during a military plane flyover at Mount Rushmore on Friday.Credit…Anna Moneymaker for The New York Times
Annie Karni
Maggie Haberman

By Annie Karni and Maggie Haberman

  • July 4, 2020Updated 8:03 p.m. ET

WASHINGTON —President Trump spent the Fourth of July weekend sowing national divide, ignoring his failings on the coronavirus and vowing to fight what he branded the “new far-left fascism.”

In a speech at the White House on Saturday evening and an address in front of Mount Rushmore on Friday night, Mr. Trump promoted a version of the “American carnage” vision for the country that he laid out during his inaugural address — updated to include an ominous depiction of the recent protests over racial justice.

He signaled even more clearly that he would exploit race and cultural flash points to stoke fear among his base of white supporters in an effort to win re-election. As he has done in the past, he resorted to exaggerated, apocalyptic language in broadly tarring the nationwide protests against entrenched racism and police brutality, saying that “angry mobs” sought to “unleash a wave of violent crime in our cities” and that those seeking to deface monuments want to “end America.”

Though Mr. Trump avoided references on Friday to the symbols of the Confederacy that have been a target of many protests, referring instead to monuments of America’s “founders,” he has in the past defended statues honoring Confederate soldiers as “beautiful.” And he has resisted renaming military bases named after Confederate generals, even as military leaders signaled their support for such a move.

ADVERTISEMENTContinue reading the main story

Mr. Trump followed up with his remarks on Saturday from the South Lawn of the White House, which sounded more like a campaign rally, and repeated the themes from the previous evening.

“We will never allow an angry mob to tear down our statues, erase our history, indoctrinate our children or trample on our freedoms,” Mr. Trump said, claiming that protesters were “not interested in justice or healing.”

  • Thanks for reading The Times.

Subscribe to The Times

Mr. Trump cast himself as the heir to “American heroes” who defeated Nazis, fascists, communists and terrorists, all but drawing a direct line from such enemies to his domestic critics.

“We are now in the process of defeating the radical left, the Marxists, the anarchists, the agitators, the looters, and people who in many instances have absolutely no clue what they are doing,” he said.

Speaking to an audience that included front-line workers like doctors and nurses working to combat the coronavirus, Mr. Trump boasted about his administration’s response, even as more than 129,000 Americans have died and local officials in Washington warned against hosting a large gathering for the Independence Day holiday this year. Few on the White House South Lawn were wearing masks.

Editors’ Picks

Welcome to Your School Reunion! No Name Tags RequiredTwo Wealthy Sri Lankan Brothers Became Suicide Bombers. But Why?The Reality Behind ‘Below Deck’Continue reading the main story

ADVERTISEMENTContinue reading the main story

The president repeated his false claim that an abundance of testing made the country’s cases look worse than they were because they “show cases, 99 percent of which are totally harmless.” And he raised expectations for a vaccine “long before the end of the year.”

His remarks at Rushmore, and repeated from the grounds of the White House, were a reflection of his dire political standing as he nears the end of his first term in office. Mr. Trump is trailing former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr., the presumptive Democratic nominee, in national and battleground polls; lacks a booming economy or a positive message to campaign on as he tries to assign blame elsewhere for the spread of the coronavirus; and is leaning on culture wars instead to buoy his base of white supporters.

Sticking closely to the remarks on his teleprompter for both sets of remarks, with none of the joking and sarcastic asides that pepper his rally remarks, Mr. Trump delivered his speeches in a grim monotone that he often employs when reading from a script. His address had little of the celebration and joyfulness that presidents typically try to convey on the Fourth of July,

The speeches were drafted for Mr. Trump by his regular team of writers in the West Wing, who are led by Stephen Miller. Campaign officials said Saturday that they thought the speeches struck the right note for the moment

Campaign officials have repeatedly said they expect backlash against the progressive “cancel culture” movement to help the president’s standing with white suburban female voters, who they believe to be frightened by images of chaos in the city streets. But that backlash has yet to reveal itself in polls: A recent New York Times/Siena College survey showed that 75 percent of moderates and even 53 percent of somewhat conservative voters have a favorable opinion of Black Lives Matter.

Central to Mr. Trump’s approach, however, is a belief he and some of his advisers share that voters are misleading pollsters about their support for the nationwide protests, several allies said. As he has sought to present himself as the candidate of law and order, Mr. Trump has rejected suggestions from some aides who have urged him to do more to address racism in America, in the aftermath of the killing of George Floyd in the custody of police officers in Minneapolis.Sign up to receive our On Politics newsletter, a daily guide to the political news cycle.Sign Up

Instead, he has intensified his criticism of the Black Lives Matter movement. In a post last week on Twitter, he called the words Black Lives Matter a “symbol of hate” as he criticized plans by the mayor of New York City, Bill de Blasio, to paint the phrase on Fifth Avenue outside Trump Tower.

ADVERTISEMENTContinue reading the main story

In this election, Mr. Trump is campaigning in much different circumstances: As an incumbent president, he will be judged more on his record than his rhetoric.

The searing tone he has adopted is in large part aimed at consolidating support within his own party. Private Republican polling indicates the president is slipping in red states, in large part because conservative-leaning voters are unsettled.

A recent Pew survey found that just 19 percent of Republicans said they were satisfied with “the way things are going,” down from 55 percent of Republican respondents in a previous version of the same poll.

“Trump needs — or thinks he needs — fear of ‘the other’ to motivate his base and create enthusiasm,” said Christine Matthews, a Republican pollster. “Right now, people are fearful of Covid-19, but that is inconvenient for Trump, so he is trying to kick up fear about something he thinks will benefit his re-election: angry mobs of leftists tearing down American history.”

Ms. Matthews noted that his rhetoric does little more than solidify the voters who were already likely to return to his corner. “He has no interest at all in expanding his base or even pulling back in those who have departed,” she said.

Patrick Murray, the director of the Monmouth University Polling Institute, said that past presidents have typically sought to diffuse cultural battles, “giving people this amorphous kind of middle where they can continue to live.” Mr. Trump, however, is unlike any of his predecessors.

“Donald Trump does not give you that choice — you are either with him or against him,” said Mr. Murray, whose latest survey this week showed Mr. Biden leading 53 percent to 41 percent. “He is forcing people to take sides. And when they take sides, more of them are moving to the other side.”

ADVERTISEMENTContinue reading the main story

In Mr. Biden, Mr. Trump also faces a centrist opponent who is not easily branded as a radical liberal, but rather one who is seen as a palatable alternative to some older voters and Republicans in a way that Hillary Clinton was not. Mr. Biden, for instance, has said he does not support defunding the police, and has made careful distinctions between tearing down monuments to the country’s founding fathers and those commemorating Confederate leaders.

That hasn’t stopped the Trump campaign from claiming that in the black-and-white world it wants to present to voters in November, Mr. Biden is on the side of violent looters. “The first instinct of Joe Biden and his party is to agree with the agitators that there is something fundamentally wrong with America and that there always has been,” Mr. Murtaugh said.

The question for Mr. Trump and his political advisers is whether branding Mr. Biden as a puppet for far-left extremists will work.

Mr. Trump’s Friday night speech also revealed the president’s concern about his standing with evangelical voters and conservatives, who were crucial to his victory in 2016. On the list of great Americans that he said he wants to erect a statute to honor was the late Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, a conservative favorite.

In some ways, the divisive place that Mr. Trump has landed on Independence Day is where he has always felt most comfortable campaigning. “He’s totally opportunistic,” said William Kristol, the conservative writer and prominent “Never Trump” Republican.

He noted that Mr. Trump had never weighed in on the immigration debate before he made building a wall along the Mexican border the signature issue of his 2016 presidential campaign because he saw that it worked. “If you don’t care about damaging the country and abandoned normal guardrails of presidential discourse,” Mr. Kristol said, “you just keep trying things and hope something sticks.”

Jonathan Martin contributed reporting from Washington, and Shane Goldmacher from New York.

Our 2020 Election Guide

Updated July 2, 2020

  • The Latest
  • Election Results
  • Biden’s V.P. Search
    • Here are 13 women who have been under consideration to be Joe Biden’s running mate, and why each might be chosen — and might not be.
  • Keep Up With Our Coverage
    • Get an email recapping the day’s news
    • Download our mobile app on iOS and Android and turn on Breaking News and Politics alerts

ADVERTISEMENTContinue reading the main storyThanks for reading The Times.Expand your horizons with a Times subscription.Thanks for reading The Times.

EXPANDAdd more meaning to your world.Subscribe to The Times.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial

Enjoy this blog? Please spread the word :)

Follow by Email
Scroll to Top